Hall of Fame - listed by years
1980
| Name | Class of | Sport |
| John W. Hammond | 1925 | All Around |
| Saul W. Mariaschin | 1947 | Basketball |
| Geoffrey Platt | 1927 | Crew |
| Carroll M. Lowenstein | 1952 | Football |
| William M. Meigs | 1956 | Football |
| Edward A. Cooney, Jr. | 1955 | Golf |
| William J. Cleary, Jr. | 1956 | Ice Hockey |
| Charles B. Flynn | 1956 | Ice Hockey |
| Philip B. Waring | 1954 | Lacrosse |
| Dexter S. Lewis | 1956 | Lacrosse |
| Tenley E Albright | 1955 | Skating |
| David F. Hawkins | 1956 | Swimming & Diving |
| James P. Jorgensen | 1956 | Swimming & Diving |
| Robert Rittenburg | 1955 | Track & Field |
| John H. Lee Jr | 1953 | Wrestling |