Hall of Fame - listed by years
1971
| Name | Class of | Sport |
| Thomas Herbert Bilodeau | 1937 | Baseball |
| Ulysses J. Lupien, Jr. | 1939 | Baseball |
| Walter Laurence Crampton | 1936 | Boxing |
| William Albert Smith | 1936 | Boxing |
| Edward Howard Bennett, Jr. | 1937 | Crew |
| ”James Fletcher “”Spike””” Chace | 1938 | Crew |
| Dudley Talbot | 1939 | Crew |
| Charles Brewer | 1896 | Football |
| Joseph Francis Nee | 1938 | Football |
| Vernon Henry Struck | 1938 | Football |
| Clarence Elijah Boston | 1939 | Football |
| Clifford Walker Wilson | 1939 | Football |
| George Steven Ford | 1937 | Ice Hockey |
| George French Roberts | 1938 | Ice Hockey |
| Francis Austin Harding Jr | 1939 | Ice Hockey |
| Charles George Hutter, Jr. | 1938 | Swimming & Diving |
| Elisha Russel Greenwood, Jr. | 1939 | Swimming & Diving |
| Alexander C. Northrop | 1938 | Track & Field |
| Pat Orr Johnson | 1933 | Wrestling |
| Richard Glover Ames | 1934 | Wrestling |
| John Cheesman Harkness | 1938 | Wrestling |