Hall of Fame - listed by years
1969
| Name | Class of | Sport |
| William Barry Wood, Jr. | 1932 | All Around |
| John Newton Barbee, Jr. | 1928 | Baseball |
| Howard Walter Burns | 1928 | Baseball |
| George Everett Donaghy | 1929 | Baseball |
| Edward Henry McGrath | 1931 | Baseball |
| Charles Devens | 1932 | Baseball |
| John Watts | 1928 | Crew |
| Arthur Eugene French | 1929 | Football |
| David Guarnaccia | 1929 | Football |
| Eliot Thwing Putnam | 1929 | Football |
| Benjamin Holt Ticknor, II | 1931 | Football |
| Edmund Austin Mays, Jr. | 1932 | Football |
| John Peirce Chase | 1928 | Ice Hockey |
| Joseph Morrill, Jr. | 1928 | Ice Hockey |
| Rene Francis Galbraith Giddens | 1930 | Ice Hockey |
| James Luther Reid | 1929 | Track & Field |
| Norwood Penrose Hallowell, Jr. | 1932 | Track & Field |
| Eugene Edwin Record | 1932 | Track & Field |