Hall of Fame - listed by sport
Football
| Name | Class of | Year Inducted |
| Bernard Walton Trafford | 1893 | 1967 |
| Marshall Newell | 1894 | 1967 |
| Charles Brewer | 1896 | 1971 |
| Benjamin Harrison Dibblee | 1899 | 1967 |
| Percy Duncan Haughton | 1899 | 1967 |
| Charles Dudley Daley | 1901 | 1967 |
| David John Campbell | 1902 | 1967 |
| Francis Hardon Burr | 1909 | 1967 |
| Hamilton Fish | 1910 | 1967 |
| Lothrop Withington | 1911 | 1967 |
| Charles Edward Brickley | 1915 | 1970 |
| Huntington Reed Hardwick | 1915 | 1967 |
| Stanley Bagg Pennock | 1915 | 1967 |
| Walter Henry Trumbull | 1915 | 1967 |
| Edward William Mahan | 1916 | 1967 |
| Edward Lawrence Casey | 1919 | 1968 |
| Charles Arthur Clark | 1919 | 1968 |
| Arnold Horween | 1920 | 1968 |
| Thomas Smith Woods, Jr. | 1920 | 1968 |
| Charles Joseph Hubbard | 1924 | 1968 |
| Arthur Eugene French | 1929 | 1969 |
| David Guarnaccia | 1929 | 1969 |
| Eliot Thwing Putnam | 1929 | 1969 |
| Benjamin Holt Ticknor, II | 1931 | 1969 |
| Edmund Austin Mays, Jr. | 1932 | 1969 |
| Carl H. Hageman | 1933 | 1995 |
| Irad Benjamin Hardy, Jr. | 1933 | 1970 |
| David Eli Kopans | 1934 | 1970 |
| Herman Gundlach | 1935 | 1993 |
| Joseph Francis Nee | 1938 | 1971 |
| Vernon Henry Struck | 1938 | 1971 |
| Clarence Elijah Boston | 1939 | 1971 |
| Clifford Walker Wilson | 1939 | 1971 |
| Torbert Hart MacDonald | 1940 | 1973 |
| Francis Matthew Lee | 1942 | 1972 |
| Loren Greenwood Mackinney | 1942 | 1972 |
| Endicott Peabody, II | 1942 | 1972 |
| John Winters Fisher | 1945 | 1973 |
| Wallace J. Flynn | 1946 | 2000 |
| Kenneth Philip O’Donnell | 1949 | 1974 |
| Thomas H. Gannon | 1950 | 1978 |
| Howard E. Houston | 1950 | 1978 |
| Carroll M. Lowenstein | 1952 | 1980 |
| T. Jefferson Coolidge | 1954 | 1978 |
| John C. Culver | 1954 | 1978 |
| William M. Meigs | 1956 | 1980 |
| Theodore N. Metropoulos | 1957 | 1981 |
| Robert T. Shaunessy | 1959 | 1983 |
| Chester J. Boulris | 1960 | 1986 |
| Charles D. Ravenel | 1961 | 1991 |
| Stephen C. Diamond | 1967 | 1991 |
| Robert S. Leo | 1967 | 1991 |
| Alan D. Bersin | 1968 | 1995 |
| Robert T. Brooks | 1968 | 1996 |
| Donald J. Chiofaro | 1968 | 1993 |
| Carter U. Lord | 1968 | 1993 |
| Richard S. Zimmerman | 1968 | 1993 |
| Victor E. Gatto, Jr. | 1969 | 1995 |
| Gary L. Singleterry | 1970 | 1999 |
| Gary W. Farneti | 1971 | 1996 |
| David A. Ignacio | 1972 | 1996 |
| Ted DeMars | 1973 | 1999 |
| James W. Stoeckel | 1974 | 1997 |
| Milton A. Holt | 1975 | 1998 |
| Patrick J. McInally | 1975 | 1997 |
| Danny M. Jiggetts | 1976 | 1997 |
| William D. Emper | 1977 | 1999 |
| Thomas M. Joyce | 1977 | 2000 |
| James P. Kubacki | 1977 | 1998 |
| Thomas P. Winn | 1977 | 1998 |
| Robert C. Baggott, Jr. | 1978 | 1999 |
| Charles F. Durst | 1981 | 2003 |
| James L. Callinan | 1982 | 2004 |
| Joseph K. Azelby | 1984 | 2002 |
| Roger E. Caron | 1984 | 2002 |
| Thomas J. Yohe | 1989 | 2004 |